A smart contract is code that carries out rules exactly as written. Ethereum's documentation defines it as a program that runs on the blockchain, made of code (its functions) and data (its state) at a specific address. No user controls it. Once deployed, it runs as programmed, and it can define rules like a regular contract and enforce them automatically.¹ For securities, the useful questions are what that automation handles well and where it stops.
What smart contracts can do
1. Smart contracts enforce rules automatically because anyone can call them as an open API, and they can call other contracts, which Ethereum calls composability.¹
2. They reduce single points of failure because a multisig contract requires several valid signatures before a transaction executes, which divides responsibility among parties.¹
3. They can build compliance into a security token because ERC-3643, a token standard that builds on ERC-20, adds extra functions to ensure compliance in transactions of security tokens, using an onchain validator system and onchain identities for eligibility checks. The receiver must be whitelisted and verified on the identity registry.²
4. They support compliance and distribution controls because DTCC's tokenization page says token controls support compliance and oversight, and that smart contracts may automate certain compliance requirements and distribution controls.³
What smart contracts cannot do
1. A smart contract cannot respond to real-world events on its own because it cannot retrieve data from offchain sources, which Ethereum says is by design, since relying on outside information could jeopardize consensus.¹ The workaround is an oracle, and oracles have weak points of their own. Our blog on the oracle problem explains how they work and where they can fail.
2. A smart contract cannot be undone after deployment because, by default, it cannot be deleted and interactions with it are irreversible.¹
3. Smart contracts cannot be bug-proof because their code can contain flaws. In June 2016, an attacker found a recursive calling vulnerability in The DAO and called its split function again from inside itself, collecting ether many times in a single transaction.⁴ The Ethereum Foundation said the flaw sat in the DAO's code and that Ethereum itself was safe.⁴
4. Smart contracts cannot decide what the parties meant because U.S. law gives them legal effect but does not settle what the parties intended when the code and the written terms disagree.⁵
Immutability sounds good until a security needs a correction. The industry handles that with upgradable contracts and with administrative controls built into the standard itself. OpenZeppelin's documentation explains that smart contracts are immutable by design, then describes a proxy pattern in which the logic contract can be swapped while the address users interact with stays the same.⁶ Someone holds the right to make that swap, so the question of trust moves to whoever controls the keys. ERC-3643 builds in a similar control. Its mint and forced-transfer functions only require the receiver to be whitelisted and verified, and they bypass the standard's compliance rules.²
Whoever holds those keys also holds the legal questions: if an administrator can swap a contract's logic or force a transfer, then what the code says and what the parties agreed to may not always line up, and U.S. law has not fully settled which one controls. These are the kind of problems Nant Global Finance works on every day through its subsidiaries. For market participants exploring smart contracts, connect with the Nant Global Finance team at media@nantglobalfinance.com.
Sources: 1 Ethereum.org (opens in a new tab) | 2 Ethereum Improvement Proposals (ERC-3643) (opens in a new tab) | 3 DTCC (opens in a new tab) | 4 Ethereum Foundation (opens in a new tab) | 5 Skadden (opens in a new tab) | 6 OpenZeppelin (opens in a new tab)
This blog contains “forward-looking statements” as defined in the Private Securities Litigation Reform Act of 1995. You can identify forward-looking statements as those that are not historical in nature, particularly those that use terminology such as “may,” “should,” “expects,” “anticipates,” “contemplates,” “estimates,” “believes,” “plans,” “projected,” “predicts,” “potential” or “hopes” or the negative of these or similar terms. The reader is cautioned not to rely on these forward-looking statements. This communication does not constitute an offer to sell securities or the solicitation of an offer to buy securities in any jurisdiction where such offer or solicitation is not permitted.
The Nant Global Finance, Inc (“Nant”) family includes entities that are members of FINRA/SIPC and/or the NFA. Investment services are only provided by the Nant subsidiaries that are registered with the SEC, FINRA, CFTC and/or the NFA. Investment products are not FDIC insured and are subject to investment risks, including the possible loss of all principal amount invested. Establishing an account with a Nant subsidiary does not establish a relationship with Nant or any other Nant subsidiary. Each Nant subsidiary has its own independent management team and operates under its own policies and procedures. Each subsidiary is responsible for the content on its own site.
AOS Inc. dba TradingBlock is a member of FINRA, SIPC and NFA. Digital Offering, LLC and NantX Global Capital, LLC are members of FINRA and SIPC. Equity Stock Transfer and BlockAgent are transfer agents registered with U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission.
Learn more about our subsidiaries registered with FINRA on FINRA’s Broker Check
Learn more about our subsidiaries registered with the NFA on the NFA Basic Search
